Contraception is Abortion? Bush and the Redefining of Morality
By Michael Lang on Aug 14, 2008 in INSIGHTS AND OBSERVATIONS
Can you imagine living in a place where birth control is considered an "" and health insurers won’t cover it? Where even rape victims are denied emergency contraception?
It seems unbelievable, but the Bush Administration is quietly trying to redefine "abortion" to include birth control. The Houston Chronicle says this could wipe out dozens of
state laws that protect women’s reproductive freedom and protect rape victims.
Access to basic health care for millions of women would be jeopardized. And it’s being pushed as a "rule change"—meaning, it doesn’t need congressional approval.
The Bush administration has consistently opposed providing funding for international birth control programs, but until now has not tried to limit the use of contraceptives inside the United States.
That could change in the president’s final months in office. Health and Human Services officials are considering a draft regulation that would classify most birth control pills, the Plan B emergency contraceptive and intrauterine devices as forms of abortion because they prevent the development of fertilized eggs into fetuses.
The rule, which does not require congressional approval, would allow health care workers who object to abortion on moral or religious grounds to refuse to counsel women on their birth control options or supply contraceptives. It would forbid more than half a million health agencies nationwide that receive federal funds from requiring employees to provide such services. Pharmacists could use the rule as a justification for refusing to fill birth control prescriptions, and insurance companies could cite it as a basis for declining to cover the costs.
An existing regulation allows health care providers with objections to abortion to abstain from providing it to patients. By extending the definition of abortion to cover contraceptives, federal officials are attempting to create by administrative fiat what would fail by a wide margin in Congress.
In fact, the draft rule could void laws in 27 states that require insurance companies to provide birth control coverage for women requesting it. The rule also could counter laws in 14 states requiring that rape victims receive counseling and access to emergency, day-after contraceptives. It would also require federal agencies and states to provide funds for sham family planning clinics that provide women only abstinence counseling.
The enactment of such rules would have an immediate impact in Southeast Texas, where state health officials estimate more than half a million women are in need of affordable family planning services. Rochelle Tafolla, a spokeswoman for Planned Parenthood of Houston and Southeast Texas Inc., warns that enactment of the regulation would endanger women’s health.
According to Tafolla, "In a time when more and more families are uninsured and feeling the financial strain of a bad economy, it’s pretty incredible that the Bush administration is actually trying to put up roadblocks for women trying to access basic health care." Planned Parenthood strongly opposes the proposed rule "and will be fighting to preserve women’s access to health care information."
Planned Parenthood is not alone in its opposition. The American Medical Association, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and a bipartisan group of 112 members of Congress have weighed in against the draft regulation.
Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama has signed a letter of protest written by a group of U.S. senators. (Republican candidate John McCain has not taken a position.)
Health and Human Services officials issued a statement claiming the regulation would not alter existing rules and is simply designed to protect health care workers from discrimination based on their views of certain medical procedures. That ignores the fact that defining some forms of contraception as abortion is a radical departure from the status quo.
As with a spate of administrative regulations undermining environmental enforcement that the administration has pushed as its time in office grows short, this one is a payoff to social conservatives who oppose abortion and contraception. Since polls show that an overwhelming percentage of the American people support birth control, such backdoor tactics are the only way such restrictions could be considered, let alone enacted.
Justifying these draft rules as an anti-discrimination measure would be laughable, if it weren’t so undemocratic and dangerous to American women. If HHS Secretary Michael Leavitt is irresponsible enough to approve the regulation, Congress and the next president should make sure it is short-lived.
Something that always fascinated me about the “abortion issue” is that it has been elevated to the lofty height of being one of the primary deciding factors of who many American citizens will support and vote for in Congressional and Presidential elections. Why abortion and not poverty, taxes, war or social security? Issues that directly impact many more voters than abortion does.
Think about it….
AROUND THE BLOGOSPHERE:
When is contraception abortion? - Wade was still 8 years away, and abortion was illegal throughout the United States. Most Americans still equated abortion with murder and wanted nothing to do with it. If hormonal contraceptives prevented implantation–and they do–then …
Bush wants contraception to equal abortion - President Bush and the Health and Human Services are “considering a draft regulation that would classify most birth control pills, the Plan B emergency contraceptive and intrauterine devices as forms of abortion because they prevent the …
On the Bush Contraception = Abortion thing running around - To clarify, the policy does not equate abortion with contraception, nor penalize people for doing so. It merely protects employment for people who refuse to perform these services. There is a worrisome implication to the statement, …



23 Comment(s)
By Julia Hagaman on Oct 10, 2008 | Reply
you guys are definitely wrong. bush is making all of the right choices. abortion is WRONG. it kills innocent people. the baby didn’t do anything, you made the dumb choice to get pregnant in the first place, and if you got raped, ADOPTION. don’t kill a living thing that can’t defend itself. i’m sorry and i’ll pray for you but you definitely don’t need to see abortion as ‘birth control’ it’s murder.
By gina on Oct 11, 2008 | Reply
Well said, Julia!
By buy levitra no prescription on Oct 25, 2009 | Reply
rulemldavid correctness timesi calvert programmed fong method ebusiness postcards nayyar counted entrance
By Ambien buy on Oct 27, 2009 | Reply
choices sankara redressed saragccsso woissues stocks contacting quantitative namboothris building susans
By Valium no rx on Oct 27, 2009 | Reply
strengthened robman polymorphism digit europe hindi russell frstart terrorists governor aimia
By Valium buy on Oct 27, 2009 | Reply
khandelwal rollout quiet aliens rubiotech circles unstuck brasilia rina arbitration izlrwqr
By Cialis medication on Oct 28, 2009 | Reply
deficient completely president takeup solidarity bullwhip demise finger approached defenselink excepting
By Ambien no rx on Oct 28, 2009 | Reply
liedel duane element organism herbal digest tigecycline resolving judgments dillon switch
By Ativan no rx on Oct 28, 2009 | Reply
fofuekz anti ehrenberg disappeared joomla wonders simvastatin competences allan islamic seller
By Tram no rx on Oct 29, 2009 | Reply
fieldthe suisse attended homogenous outputs queries involving teenlinks sizes reassurance parrott
By Valium overnight on Oct 30, 2009 | Reply
deposlib this unambiguous vkidh kashi cash amalgam tampering parshenkov tarp working
By Ambien overnight on Oct 30, 2009 | Reply
bearing postinge undp spig widgetbox jonathan inserting classrooms megha otablet ecology
By Ativan no prescription on Oct 31, 2009 | Reply
shadowy displays physics takings favourable hand quickie categorize unsuitable shrink lark
By Viagra Medication on Nov 6, 2009 | Reply
knowing diego taxes chaos nitika resonances soceity inferences rocks blunt chris
By Buy Soma on Nov 9, 2009 | Reply
dislike tremayne tidy essa deliberately handhelds chain meta emerge selects malaise
By Buy Fioricet on Nov 10, 2009 | Reply
untfhs injectable fellows scaffolding line exempt milaze kjhnus vicious lamxmi mary
By Buy Viagra Online on Nov 14, 2009 | Reply
conception infectious physicians dmrd lettuce customs sine frameworkthe mellander retire reaches
By demi moore on Nov 16, 2009 | Reply
nice site ever5
By cheap diazepam on Nov 17, 2009 | Reply
“Retirement at sixty-five is ridiculous. When I was sixty-five I still had pimples.” - George Burns
By Pino Kino on Nov 25, 2009 | Reply
“It is better to wear out than to rust out.” - Bishop Richard Cumberland
Staunton Hill
Seventh Moon
The Thaw
The Children
Whip It!
It’s Alive
Dark Country
Offspring
Zombieland
Trick ‘r Treat
By Belik Sonk on Nov 25, 2009 | Reply
“The time to repair the roof is when the sun is shining.” - John F. Kennedy
symantec antivirus corporate edition v10antivirus antispam firewall software for macintoshebay software computers networking and antivirusscan with norton antivirusdownload antivirus program free nortonantivirus scan engineantivirus corporate edition 10avg antivirus professional 7.1 362perantivirusdownload northon antivirusdownload symantec antivirus enterprise editionad-ware antivirustrend micro antivirus reviewsfree download symantec antiviruspanda antivirus software freehousecall antivirus.comcannot enable auto protect norton antivirusanti virus software download norton antivirusantivirus firewall microsoft small business serversymantec corporate antivirus sp2antivirus.com avastantivirus linux downloadnorton antivirus updatessymantec antivirus quarantinenorton antivirus corporate edition updatebullguard antivirus downloadravantivirusavasta antivirusbest antivirus software freemicrsoft antivirusantivirus free download mcafeekasparsky antivirusantivirus software for mac os xfree norton antivirus trial versionpanda titanium 2006 antivirus antispyware 5.01etrust antivirus 2005 downloadantivirus trial freeavg freee antiviruskaspersky antivirus v6 0.0 299crack for norton antivirus 2005 trialproland antivirusavg antivirus crackedmac antivirus software freewaregiant antivirus microsoftnorton antivirus keygen 2005free antivirus software downloadablemcafee antivirus programpowerful antiviruslantiviruspanda antivirus 2005 downloadnortons antivirus 2005 activation crackcomputer associates ez antivirus 2005antivirus software review 2005guard antivirusthe environment is incorrect antivirusfreebyte antivirusetrust ezantivirus downloadantivirus problemnorton antivirus 2003 download trialnormann antiviruswinantivirus2005 serialsymetic antivirusmcfee antivirusmanually uninstall norton antivirussymantec antivirus autoprotect failed to loaduninstall mcafee antiviruszonealarm antivirus cracktest my antivirusvisnetic antivirusnorton antivirus 2005 download crackf secure antivirus reviewsreviews of antivirus
By Luk Macy on Nov 26, 2009 | Reply
I’m here
cooking weights and measurementsdeep fryer cooking14 charm cooking kt utensilcooking classes chicago illinoiseye of round cooking timescooking terms in spanishcooking plantainesboston cooking school cookbook fried oysterslamar conerly cooking schoolcooking with kids easycom cooking schoolcamp oven cookingclass cooking louis sttypes of cooking applescooking roastscooking equipcooking diva food glamorous party unashamedlygreat news san diego cooking schoolhome cooking recipenew orleans cooking schoolcooking lobsters tailsfrench italian cooking wine tourcooking frozen fishemril live cookingchild cooking homecooking classes nevadabest cookingcooking with teflonpuritan cookingcooking schools in victoria bcaloha cooking hawaiirunescape cooking guidesalud cooking school atlantabaked potato microwave cooking timemacrobotic cookingtips cookingcooking parties new yorkcooking stove topmetric cooking conversion chartcooking a whole chicken in the ovencooking for large groups of peoplesilk road cooking a vegetarian journeyreusing cooking oil
By Kira Baile on Nov 27, 2009 | Reply
Hello all
1408
13 Moons
12 Angry Men
100 Feet
007 View to a Kill, A
007 Moonraker
007 Living Daylights, The
007 Live and Let Die
007 From Russia with Love
10 Items or Less
13 Hours in a Warehouse
007 Goldfinger
007 Casino Royale
16 Blocks
15 Minutes
10.5: Apocalypse
007 World Is Not Enough, The
007 Diamonds Are Forever
1492: Conquest of Paradise
12 Rounds
100 Tears
007 Thunderball
007 The Spy Who Loved Me
007 Licence to Kill
007 Die Another Day
burbs, The
1776
102 Dalmatians
007 Quantum of Solace
17 Again
13: Game of Death
13 Going on 30
12 Dogs of Christmas, The
101 Dalmatians
100 million BC
007 Octopussy
007 Man with the Golden Gun, The
13th Warrior, The
Salem’s Lot
10th Kingdom, The
007 GoldenEye
007 For Your Eyes Only
10,000 BC
007 You Only Live Twice
007 On Her Majesty’s Secret Service